Policy Unstuck with David TC Davies, the former Secretary of State for Wales. Interviewed, edited, and titled by Tom Hashemi.
What Rishi talked about at supper
As Secretary of State I had masses going on. At one point I was trying to add a very minor clause to a digital bill, about the Office for National Statistics’ powers to get data more easily from the Welsh Government. A message came back from Number 10, special adviser to special adviser, that the Prime Minister [Rishi Sunak] wanted it stopped. I exploded: ‘Please don’t tell me the Prime Minister has time to be bothering with trivial stuff like this. This is someone in Number 10 trying to save themselves some work.’
A few days later I mentioned it to Rishi. He said, ‘Oh yes, I thought we’d already agreed that wasn’t going to happen.’ So he knew all about it, as well as everything else I was doing, and presumably everything the other 20 or so secretaries of state were doing. It was impressive: I don’t know where he found the time.
Rishi never barked orders from on high. He’d invite a few cabinet ministers round for an informal supper, and the conversation wasn’t ‘where are you going on holiday?’ but was ‘what’s on your desk?’ You’d quickly discover he knew almost as much about your issues as you did. He wasn’t trying to tell you what to do; he was making sure you knew what you were doing. I never went to one of those suppers without being certain I was across the detail.
Explain it to me like I’m ten
I’ve had people come in and fire an argument at me with loads of jargon, and my feeling—call me cynical—was that I was expected to nod along and never admit I didn’t quite know what they were talking about. So I’d say: ‘Explain it to me like I’m ten.’ If you can’t put it into simple language, you don’t understand it yourself. You’re just repeating something written for you by someone else, or by AI.
If I’ve asked them to explain two or three times and I’m still none the wiser what they are talking about, it’s either my fault or theirs. I’ve gained enough self-confidence to think that in those situations it’s not usually my fault: most issues are simple enough if you boil them down.
I’d often ask even when I knew damn well what the issue was. It was a good way of finding out whether they did—and whether I could trust the advice they were offering.
OK, how simple is simple enough?
You should be able to explain it to a child, or to someone with no specialist knowledge, and quickly. You often need to explain things to journalists. They’re perfectly bright, but they don’t have 20 minutes. Could I have summed up what was happening with Tata in five minutes to a busy journalist, then taken questions on the detail?
Ultimately, in politics you have to get it over to the public, who have many things going on in their lives and not much time for politicians. If you can’t explain quickly what you’re doing and why it’s necessary, you’ll lose the argument anyway.
Simple explanations stand the test of time
When I was involved in the Tata deal back in 2022 [to build an electric arc furnace in Port Talbot], I wanted to understand the technical details on how steel was made. So I asked Gareth Stace from Make UK to come in and take me through it in basic terms. He was brilliant. We spent quite a while on it: the process, the supply chain, all sorts. I didn’t strictly need it, because the deal was about money and jobs, but it was hugely useful background, and I’ve remembered it ever since.
Sorry, Mark: good ideas don’t speak for themselves
I respect Mark Drakeford, but I don’t agree that good ideas speak for themselves. I’ve seen perfectly rational things go badly because they weren’t communicated properly, and ministers came unstuck because of it. I’ll give you an example…
Around 2010, the Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition government decided to sell off commercial forestry. The government owned large tracts of forest to grow and sell trees, and quite fairly didn’t want to be in the tree-growing business any more. Immediately came the cry that every forest in the country would be sold to American multinationals and nobody would be allowed to walk in them again. That was untrue, completely untrue.
I remember saying to a government whip: ‘I know what you’re trying to do, and I don’t have a problem with it: I know you’re not going to stop people walking in the forest. But I do have a problem with upsetting large numbers of my constituents who haven’t had a sensible idea explained to them properly.’ In the end, the government dropped it.
→ Good ideas don’t speak for themselves, but politicians can speak for them. Email Natallia to see how we’ve got politicians using our clients’ framing in public—by giving them language that is easy to use, and useful.
Bring in the people nobody invites
One of my pet irritations as a select committee chair was the same groups turning up to give evidence time after time. If you ran an inquiry into climate change, there’d be no shortage of groups to call, and they’d all say the same thing. The organisations that would challenge that are rarely brought in. I don’t think it’s deliberate; it’s just hard to get people to think outside the box.
About 20 years ago, on a rural affairs inquiry, I suggested bringing in the Masters of Foxhounds Association. Eyebrows went up. They’d have had a very different perspective from anyone else in the room, and it never seemed to occur to anyone that this was a good reason to bring them in, rather than a reason to keep them out.
I once brought a group in to give evidence to the Welsh Affairs Committee, probably the TaxPayers’ Alliance, and had to calm down at least one member who was asking rather aggressively what right they had to be there. I said: ‘Look, they’ve got a different point of view. It’s one you aren’t going to like, but at least let them have their say.’
If you want to make an argument, in the media or in Parliament, you have to understand the alternative point of view as well, and recognise that there is one. I’d always like to hear the other perspective, even if it’s one I don’t agree with, just so I understand it.
Thank you to the 153 of you who have referred colleagues to this newsletter. The views expressed in Policy Unstuck interviews are those of the interviewee, and do not necessarily represent Cast from Clay’s view. You can read our editorial guidelines for more information on the goals, process, and formatting of this series.


